Probably one of the two most contentious issues during soccer games are offside decisions (the other is ‘handball’). This comes up during pretty much every game – coaches and parents protesting ‘obvious’ bad offside calls by the referees.
I’m not going to get into the technicalities of precisely what offside is here, but if you want further background please click here for a blog post that includes a discussion of offside and why it’s so very difficult to determine unless you are the AR in the right position. Even the CR can’t make that decision unless it’s blatantly obvious.
Instead, let’s take a look at a very difficult offside decision during a very recent EPL Liverpool game.
First, what does this screen shot tell you? White #8 is clearly offside, correct? He’s closer to the goal than the red defenders when his teammate heads the ball towards him.
Next, let’s rotate our field of view. What does this next screen shot show?
It clearly shows White #8 NOT in an offside position because he is level with Red #11 the moment his teammate heads the ball towards him.
Quite amazing the difference the angle of view makes, right?
However, the play isn’t over yet. Let’s take a look at the next screen shot.
The white player at the top headed the ball towards White #8, but it lands short in front of the white player barely visible in front of Red #6. Both that white player and Red #6 stretch their left leg to reach the ball.
The moment the white player’s leg touches the ball is another potential offside infraction by White #8. However, White #8 is again NOT in an offside position because the red player’s outstretched left leg (or more precisely his left foot) is closer to the goal than any body part of White #8 (please note that hands and arms don’t count for offside decisions).
The ball then landed in front of White #8 who scored. The referees rightfully awarded the goal.
Now imagine all this unfolding in realtime and you’re one of the referees. This is very difficult to get right unless you are highly trained and have the experience to apply the laws of the game in realtime as the action unfolds.
Please consider giving the referees the benefit of doubt during your youth games. Referees do make mistakes, of course, and they are the first to admit it, but please keep in mind that coaches and parents simply aren’t close enough to the action, nor have the right angle of view, nor fully understand the offside law and how to apply it.
For the good of the game and your kid’s enjoyment please think twice before reacting to an ‘obvious’ offside ‘mistake’.
2 thoughts on “Offside during recent Liverpool game”
Excellent, James. Short, simple must-read for all U8 comp parents who all have an opinion but have never read the LOTG. Actually, there are U15 parents who also don’t know the LOTG…..
Thank you, Patrick. Please share widely so we can help educate folks. Every little piece helps calm games down.